MISCmedia for 11/24/99
Back To the (More Likely) Future

ON MONDAY AND TUESDAY, I'd discussed Looking Backward, Edward Bellamy's 1888 utopian tract.

In it, a "refined" young man of 1880s Boston awakens from a 113-year trance to find himself in the all-enlightened, worry-free Year 2000. The doctor who'd revived him (and the doc's comely daughter) then spend the rest of the book telling him how wonderful everything has become.

The chief feature of Bellamy's future is a singular, government-run "Industrial Army" that owns all the means of production and distribution, employs every citizen aged 21-45 (except child-bearing women), and pays everybody the same wage (less-desirable jobs offer shorter hours or other non-monetary perks).

Obviously, nothing like that ever happened. Soviet communisim was a police-state regime that used egalitarian ideals to justify its brutality. Euro-socialism featured government-owned industrial companies that operated just like privately-owned companies, only less efficiently and less profitably.

But could Bellamy's fantasy have ever worked in anything close to its pure form? Undoubtedly not.

It would've required that everybody (or at least enough people to impose their will on the rest) submit to a single, purified ideology based on rationality and selflessness. Any uncensored history of any major religious movement shows how impossible that is, even within a single generation.

We are an ambitious and competitive species. The "rugged individualist" notion, long exploited by U.S. corporations and advertisers, has a real basis in human nature.

We are also a diverse species. Especially in the U.S. whose citizens are gathered from the whole rest of the world. Bellamy's totalized mass society would require a social re-engineering project even greater, and more uprooting, than that of the steam-age society he'd lived in. The kindly-doctor character's insistence that all these changes had coalesced peacefully, as an inevitable final stage of industrial consolidation, may be the least likely-seeming prediction in the whole tome.

As I wrote previously, most utopian fantasies require that everybody in a whole society conform to the writer's prescribed sensibility. (Some even require that everybody belong to the writer's own gender or race.)

In most cases, the prescribed sensibility is that of a writer, or at least of a planner--ordered, systematic, more knowledgeable about structures than about people.

The impossibility of such monocultural utopias hasn't stopped writers and planners from thinking them up. But at least some folks are realizing any idealized future has to acknowledge that people are different from one another and always will be.

We'll talk more about this idea of a post-mass, post-postmodern future in future weeks.

TOMORROW: Musings on Biggest-Shopping-Day Eve.

ELSEWHERE:

• Who sez death can't be creative?...
• Twin Peaks still holds up after 10 years, to me and to my ol' pal Jim Emerson....
• The changing American workplace means new types of repetitive-stress injuries...

RECENT HIGHLIGHTS:

• Imagining a newspaper for the Net age.
• Some of today's more perverse, ephemeral "art forms."
• I still kvetch about arrogant San Francisco; but is Seattle now no better?
• Wacky emails received here lately, plus other fun short stuff.
• Can you tell me how to get to Coronation Street?
• Guys who fight aren't necessarily copying Fight Club.
• The history of trying to get away from it all.
• Does postmodern fiction trash old hierarchies or just build new ones; can't we just get past PoMo yet; and can we imagine a more proactive future?
• Ron Harris's journey from phony workout videos to phony human-egg auctions.
• A hipper-than-thou magazine complains when corporations don't love it; while the zine Ben Is Dead dies.
• Election '99 pitted both prog-leftys and rabble-rightys against the corporate center.
• Not-so-guilty musical pleasures.
• Could Blair Witch be considered a Dogme 95 film?
• The joys of oral surgery.
• The origins of manga/anime storytelling.

ARCHIVES:

• 2001, 2000, 1999, 1998, 1997, 1996, 1995, and 1986-94 columns
• Reviews of literature & art, monfiction & culture criticism, movies & videos, and music & noise
• Longer articles and essays
• The origin and future of MISCmedia